I echo your same thoughts, which is why I was hoping they'd modify the express use for this attraction to limit the number of guests able to utilize it. No one wins from the express line clogging up everything after 4PM with APs. I'm ok with express on this attraction if they limited access to it.
Disney's a lot better now, but I don't think Universal is as egregious as WDW was a few years ago... they just have two attractions (Velo & Hagrid) they need to adjust express procedures for.
EDIT - JULY UPDATE: Hagrid's wait-time increased by
+28% in July compared to last year. (Avg. this year is 104 versus 81 last year
Other UOR Attractions for Comparison...
- Forbidden Journey down 17%
- VelociCoaster down 24%
- Skull Island up 13%
- Spider-Man up 2%
- Hulk down 5%
- Ripsaw Falls down 12%
- The Cat in the Hat down 25%
- High in the Sky down 17%
- Revenge of the Mummy down 17%
- ET Adventure down 6%
- Gringotts up 3%
- Rockit up 37%
- Minion Blast down 53%
- Minion Mayhem down 24%
Avg. Crowd Level down 24% for USF, 18% down for IOA
I know wait-times are not the sole indicator... but it's pretty clear Express Pass has made Hagrid's a far worse queue experience for standby.
*Data according to TouringPlans